Family owned since 2011 · Serving Central IndianaCall 317-364-9511

Back to Articles

Re-Roofing Estimates: Clarify Overlay or Full Replacement

Originally published: 9/26/2026 11:15:00 AM

Worker carrying a roofing tool across a shingle roof

Updated October 20, 2026

The word re-roofing does not always describe the same scope. One proposal may mean removing the existing roofing and installing a new system; another may use the term for an overlay. Before comparing prices, ask the contractor to explain exactly what work the term covers.

Ask what will be removed

A written estimate should say whether the existing roofing is being removed and how many layers are included. Discuss the condition of the current roof, any known leaks and what can or cannot be assessed before removal. Do not assume a lower price includes the same preparation.

Understand the limits of inspection

A surface inspection cannot reveal every concealed condition. Ask how the installation method affects access to the decking and how the contractor would handle damaged areas. Suitability also depends on the building, existing materials and applicable requirements; it should be evaluated for the actual property.

Compare the finished system

Review flashing, roof-edge materials, underlayment, ventilation and the selected shingles or membrane. Ask which warranties apply to the proposed method. Roof Masters & Exteriors can assess your roof and explain repair or replacement options so the scope is clear before you choose a project.

Discuss roof replacement options or call 317-364-9511.

Components of a Complete Shingle Roof System

Your roof includes more than the shingles you see. This diagram shows the deck, underlayment, ice and water barrier, starter shingles, ridge components, and attic ventilation.

Components of a Good Roof System diagram showing shingles, hip and ridge shingles, ridge vent, underlayment, wood deck, starter shingles, ice and water barrier, gutters, attic ventilation, baffles, and insulation
Illustration of a pitched shingle roof system. Your written project scope identifies the materials and installation details selected for your property.
Open the Full Diagram

Ask Roof Masters

Automated project guide

Hi! Type a question or choose a topic below. For a personal answer, call our team at 317-364-9511.

Preset answers to common questions. Questions stay on this page; use the estimate form to contact our team.